During a client portfolio review meeting last week, I did what I always do and started at the end. Before looking at a single trade, I pulled up the pie charts that show where the portfolio would land if the client said yes to our suggestions. It’s a lot to take in at once, but it tells the story faster than a listing of transactions ever will. And this time the story was mostly about bonds.
Specifically, it was about clearing out something in the middle. The portfolio held a good chunk of what the industry calls balanced funds, which hold stocks and bonds together in one package. The concept sounds sensible, and plenty of people own them. My recommendation was to let the ones in this portfolio go and replace them with plain, dedicated stock and bond funds, so the stock side and the bond side each do one focused job.
There are two reasons we suggested eliminating these funds, and neither is complicated. The first is that the stock and bond mix inside these particular funds shifts over time, which makes it harder to know (or control) what you actually own on any given day. When I’m building a plan around a target mix, I want to be able to see and manage the category allocations. If part of the portfolio is a blend that changes on its own, the plan is steering with a fogged windshield.
The second reason is that these funds adjust their mix based on where the managers think markets are headed. Not every balanced fund works that way, but these did. I don’t have a lot of confidence that anyone, even the biggest firms in the business, can time the market consistently. Paying for that effort feels like tilting at windmills. I’d rather keep things conservative, well-diversified, and transparent with the mix set out in the open, where the client can see it and agree to it.
Once the bond allocation is clearly determined, the next question is what kind of bonds to purchase. Here I lean short. Shorter-term bonds, and the funds that hold them, are less sensitive to swings in interest rates than longer ones, which tend to fall further when rates rise. Going shorter can mean giving up a little yield, and right now I don’t think that’s much of a sacrifice. The extra yield you get for reaching further out, or for buying lower-quality bonds, is pretty thin these days. The spreads, as they call them, are low, so I don’t see much reason to go out on a limb for them.
I also proposed adding some inflation-adjusted bonds. These are Treasury bonds whose principal is adjusted for changes in the Consumer Price Index, and the interest is paid on that adjusted amount. Their market price can still drop, especially when interest rates climb, but the inflation adjustment gives some protection if inflation gets ugly. Even there, I stick to the shorter maturities, for the same reason as noted above.
Why all this attention to the “boring” part of the portfolio? Because short-term bonds have a job beyond earning interest. They aren’t cash, and they can lose value, but they usually fluctuate in price a good deal less than stocks. That makes them a sensible place to draw from when something unexpected comes up, and a cushion that lets you leave stocks alone when they’re having a rough stretch. Stocks don’t go up every year. Market drops occur on a relatively frequent basis, and when they do you don’t want to be forced to sell stocks to pay the bills. Short-term bonds are the bridge over that troubled water.
None of this is magic, and the world could look entirely different down the road. It already looks quite different than it did a few years back. That’s why I revisit our client plans regularly and make small adjustments early, before anything drifts far off track. A small change made with years of runway ahead can matter a great deal by the end.
One more thing is worth saying plainly: in our practice, every one of these changes is a recommendation. Nothing gets traded until the client has looked it over and said yes, and that’s exactly how it should work.
So here’s something to try this week. Pull up your own portfolio statement and look at the bond portion. Do you know how sensitive those holdings are to interest rates? Most bond fund fact sheets list a measure called duration, and the shorter that number, the less the fund tends to move when rates change. If you own a balanced fund, could you say how much of it sits in stocks today? If either answer is “I’m not sure,” that’s worth a conversation with your financial advisor.
